Tuesday, April 19, 2011

Social Media and the Personal Story

In past blog posts, I have written about the influence that social networking sites had on the revolutions that are happening in the Middle East and Africa. Secretary Albright also mentioned the usefulness of these tools at her recent lecture. However, little attention has been played to social media in the aftermath of the earthquake that recently hit northern Japan. Personally, I had watched that popular YouTube video of the mayor of Minami Soma City asking the international community for help in distributing necessary goods and was drawn its ability to put a personal narrative into tragic national disaster. After watching the video, the implications of the earthquake and the affects of the damaged nuclear power plan felt more real.
This story by PBS’s MediaShift collected stories from several earthquake survivors or media addicts and explains how social media cites, like Facebook and Twitter, was able to help them find survivors or establish more intricate systems to do so. While I had read many articles on the situation in Japan and about the government’s response to the nuclear reactors, this piece took a different approach and focused on the efforts of individuals. I enjoyed reading this collection of narratives, because I think it does a good job of capturing the essence of social media. Individuals are asking to share their opinions of day-to-day interactions or experiences. These profiles show the importance of collecting small pieces of information of individual users and the implications this can have on larger movements, like rescue missions and revolutions.

Monday, April 18, 2011

Breaking News in the Age of New Media

The Pulitzer Prize winners were announced today and tucked away in the awards was the prize for "Breaking News"...and no one won. There were three nominees but apparently none of them met the committee's idea of breaking news as an "example of local reporting...with special emphasis on the speed and accuracy of the initial coverage." Slate's SCOCCA blog likes to joke that the committee should have just awarded the prize to Twitter. Slate's amusing (and extremely short post) raises an interesting question of what "breaking news" means in the age of new media. Twitter with its rapid posting rates and short bits of information reaches out and touches the boundaries of whatever former conception people previously had of breaking news. So, is breaking news "defunct" as Slate's blog asserts? Would be better off ridding this term from our vernacular and our understanding of reporting? Breaking news is no longer an exception--it's the norm. Perhaps it's time that the news media starts publicly recognizing this.

"Police Lesson"

We all know about a lot of the positive benefits of social networks like Twitter and Facebook.  But what people don't often think about until its too late, is the other ramifications such sites can have.  When individuals are suspected of criminal activity, social sites are added to the list of of things the police (or other officials) check.
Social networking tools like Facebook and Twitter can be valuable assets for law enforcement agencies, helping them alert the public, seek information about crimes and gather evidence about the backgrounds of criminal suspects. 
But, in some cases this double-edged sword can also get the police in trouble.  After one police officer was involved in a fatal shooting the local news stations went to his Facebook page for reference.  There he had listed his occupation as "human waste disposal."  In another instance, the Santa Monica police department went to great lengths to conceal an injured officers identity and location, only to have it revealed on Facebook.  It is also a tool used by lawyers and can be used against police officers.
Defense lawyers increasingly scour social networking sites for evidence that could impeach a police officer’s testimony. In one case in New York, a jury dismissed a weapons charge against a defendant after learning that the arresting officer had listed his mood on MySpace as “devious” and wrote on Facebook that he was watching the film “Training Day” to “brush up on proper police procedure.”

Social networking sites are not only used by officials to regulate and check on the masses, but also to watch over the the same officials.  

Information for this article came from a New York Times report

Sunday, April 17, 2011

Royal Wedding Watch

Kate Middleton and Prince William are getting married.  But if you have read any newspaper, magazine, social media, or just been in public over the past month you probably couldn't avoid knowing that.  It has been a main topic of conversation on Twitter for weeks and most major news sites like The Washington Post, The New York Times and Huffington Post all have dedicated a section to coverage of The Royal Wedding.  

It is as big a deal in America as it is in Britain.  But is the coverage spurred by Americans' infatuation or the other way around?  Every facet of the wedding has been reported in every different medium.  Open a newspaper, log on to Twitter, Facebook, or turn on the TV and you can see every detail (available) about Kate's dress, the cake, speculation about honeymoon destinations, what Harry and Pippa will be wearing.  A majority of this extended coverage is through social media or online versions of major newspapers.  With limited space in the printed press, only highly important and timely news is printed.  But with no space constraints in the world wide web anything is possible.  Stay updated for more coverage of the Royal Wedding! 

Monday, April 11, 2011

Just a Mirage? Debating the Economic Impact of Social Media

Although the economy is currently troubled, TIME magazine points out that there is one area that is thriving: social media. Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, Groupon, Yelp, Flickr, are just some examples of companies that barely existed five years ago, but are now together worth billions. For the most part, these companies are private, but have drawn the attention of Wall Street and other investors. There is no doubt that these companies enrich their founders (e.g. Mark Zuckerberg is now the youngest billionaire in the world!) and their investors, but do they add anything to overall economic activity?

Jobs in social media are growing fast, but there were only 21,000 listings last spring, which is a tiny fraction of the 150 million-member U.S. workforce. The article poses the following questions: "Do social media tools enhance productivity or help us bridge the wealth divide? Or are they simply social--entertaining and diverting us but a wash when it comes to national economic health?" The answers to these questions are still unclear; for the most part, only time will tell.

Currently, billions of dollars in investment capital are being spent on these ventures. In order for the U.S. to have a fruitful economic future, that capital needs to "grow the economic pie and not just among the elite of Silicon Valley and Wall Street." Furthermore, as the article poignantly points out, "The U.S. retains a competitive advantage because of its ability to innovate, but if that innovation creates services that don't turn into jobs, growth and prosperity, then it does us only marginal good."

Since it's still fairly early in the game and all of these social media tools are relatively new, it is difficult to answer these questions definitively. Many of these same questions were being posed 20 years ago during the first Internet explosion: "Were Netscape and the Web enhancing our economy, or were people just spending more time at work checking out ESPN.com." The article also explains, "Official statistics weren't designed to capture benefits, and didn't--until statistics mavens at the Federal Reserve, urged on by Alan Greenspan, refined the way they measured productivity. As a result of these somewhat controversial innovations, the late 1990s became a period of substantial technology-driven gains."

Therefore, 20 years later, history may be repeating itself. There is a possibility that social media tools are indeed laying down a foundation for new industries and jobs but aren't yet registering on the statistical radar. Many companies do indeed believe that social media tools make them more competitive. "Ford and Zappos, for instance, use Twitter to market their products and address consumer complaints." Many companies have created internal ways for employees to communicate across divisions through social media, for example using Yammer. Even industry groups for engineers, doctors, and human resources professionals are using social media to share new ideas and best practices on a regular basis, instead of periodically at conferences. One senior executive at Manpower said, "we should think of social-media tools as today's version of the telephone. Yes, they are used for frivolity and all sorts of noneconomic activity (chatting with friends, passing the time), but they also help communication happen more efficiently."

One major question that lingers is "what proportion of the social media benefit will be captured economically by consumers vs. by corporations." Social media gives people the platform to share ideas, compare prices, assess which companies are good to work for, enhance education. But the major caveat is that the people using these tools are the ones who can afford to spend money on technology and have a higher education, not the tens of millions of people in the world who can barely find their next meal. A Pew Research Foundation study found that only 45% of adults making less than $30,000 have access to broadband, which is essential for using social media.

Therefore, it seems that social media is just another contributor to "economic bifurcation." There is no doubt that companies are benefiting from these tools, even if it's hard to specify any numerical gains. Individuals are benefiting too--getting good deals on Groupon, finding jobs on LinkedIn, and keeping in touch with old friends on Facebook. But as the article points out, "the irony is that social media widen the social divide, making it even harder for the have-nots to navigate." If all of the news were to transfer to Web news and be posted through social media only, what about all the people who can't afford to buy a computer or pay a monthly Internet fee, but who can afford to pay a couple dollars for a newspaper or watch free television? Are they to be left uninformed?

Saturday, April 9, 2011



On the 29th of March, the New York Times and the Washington Post reported that a Facebook page that was calling for an intifada against Jews in Israel, was removed from the social media site. But they did not follow the story: news sources in France, Germany, Israel and United Kingdom reported on April the 4th that Facebook was sued by an former American Justice department prosecutor because of that page. However, the story was covered by the Huffington Post in a really short article.

Does that mean the Huffington Post is more free than the other news sources to reassess the impact of the social media giant or that the American audience does not care?

Friday, April 8, 2011


The New York Times announced on March 27th that the former White House’s press secretary, Robert Gibbs, may be hired by Facebook. The day after, the information was analyzed by many news sources worldwide.

The Washington Post, in its business section, sets the story back into a wider trend, analyzing in a really long article, the relationship between the White House and tech companies over the years. On the contrary, Fox News only report the story in a paragraph in its media section. The same discrepancy can be found in the foreign press (at least in the French one): the main leftist newspaper covers the story, analyzing how the link between the White House and Facebook could affect the tax policy, whereas the right wing newspaper only evokes the story in two paragraphs, underlining the fact that nothing is sure for now.