Tuesday, March 29, 2011

The Obama administration announced on March the 16th they were working on a “privacy bill of right”, which aim is to control what data of internet users can be used or sell by the main internet companies. It is a sensitive subject because it matches the right of the consumer against the rights of the private companies. The two positions were summed up in the media as a competition between the European and the American model. Especially because at the same time, the European Commissaire Viviane Reding delivered a speech about the protection of private datas in the Union. Not surprisingly, many liberal media took position in favor of “the European Model” (the Huffington Post, the New York Times) whereas conservative media seem more circumspect (Fow News).

What I found really interesting is the comparison between the American coverage and the European coverage of the same subject. In Europe, everyone, from every political party, agree on the importance of having a law to guarantee the protection on the private data. The only fear is that the American companies such as google or facebook, won’t allow it.

New media, Old story


The recent story of Alexandra Wallace, a political science major from UCLA who published a video on youtube to explain she expects Asian student to adopt “American manners”, was covered by all mainstream media (The Washington Post, MSNBC…). What is surprising is that all of them, except for the New York Times, did not use that story to talk about the danger of the digital footprint people can leave on the internet. Instead, they focused on the fact that she was not expelled from school, because she was protected by the first amendment, and on racism toward Asian American.

I think this story is a perfect illustration of how the old media react to what happens in the new media such as youtube: they do not really know what to do with those news and what the issues can be so everything that happens online is linked to the right of expression. They do not even know where to classify them: that story can be found in the US section of the New York Times and in the the business section of the Washington Post and MSNBC.

Monday, March 28, 2011

Is there a new Tech Bubble waiting to Burst?


With all of the money from banks pouring into technology funds, and wealthy clients trying to get a piece of the start-up pie, some investors with memories of the dot-com burst a decade ago are wondering if this sudden surge in investments foreshadows another danger for the industry. Valuations are soaring: "Investments in Facebook and Zynga have more than quintupled the implied worth of each company in the last two years. The social shopping site Groupon is said to be considering an initial public offering that would value the company at $25 billion. Less than a year ago, the company was valued at $1.4 billion" (Rusli and Kopytoff). The New York Times' article recounts many of the investment busts from 1999 and 2000. What is frightening, however, is that there is even more money flooding the market today than there was during the dot-com bubble. The Huffington Post and SFGate reported that San Francisco technology jobs are climbing near the level of the dot-com peak and may soon surpass the dot-com era peak. Another warning sign? It's too soon to tell.

But there are some important differences between the turn-of-the-century dot-com boom and now. First of all, the market is not supersaturated with offerings; in 1999, there were "308 technology I.P.O.’s, making up about half of that year’s offerings" (Morgan Stanley data) and "In 2010, there were just 20 technology I.P.O.’s" (Thomson Reuters data). Furthermore, most of the start-ups that have investors excited are ones that have real businesses producing fast-growing revenue. "Groupon, which has been profitable since June 2009, is on track to take in billions in revenue this year" (Rusli and Kopytoff). As a result, since there is such a small elite group making up this new boom, some investors say that the potential fallout if things go badly is limited. But, as cash continues to pile up, investors fear that all this money cannot be put to work responsibly. "With only a few perceived 'winners,' some investors must be choosing losers or paying too much" (Rusli and Kopytoff).

It is interesting to note that most of these investments are going towards social networking sites like Facebook, Twitter, and LinkedIn, which is a key difference between the Internet world of today vs. ten years ago. Most of the dot-com era investments were for delivery websites or sites that were seen as what JPMorgan Chase then dubbed "essential resources to consumers." (In 1999, Chase Capital Partners invested in Kozmo.com--an online delivery service that raised hundreds of millions in venture funding. "At its height, the company’s sprawling network of orange bike messengers employed more than a thousand people. Less than two years later, it ceased operations" (Rusli and Kopytoff).)

Are today's investors taking advantage of people's every day social lives? When you log in to Facebook, you're trying to keep in touch with friends and get some news from statuses and posted links; but for Facebook, every time you login, you're making the company more money by keeping up their number of users and therefore their ad revenue. Instead of users consuming actual products or services like the dot-coms of ten years ago, today's users are building on their existing relationships--and social networking sites are making money from that. What if you stopped logging in to Facebook to turn to even newer forms of social networking that lie in our future, or even to revert to older forms like emails?
Would today's technology growth turn out to be simply a passing trend, a soon-to-pop bubble, a castle built on an ever-shifting foundation?

So will we be spared another burst bubble? Is today's technology sector truly different than that of the dot-com era? Has the ever evolving relationship between society and technology finally solidified sufficiently to allow for responsible investing? We shall wait and see.

Social Networks and Elections: What To Consider for 2012 and Beyond

The New York Times wrote about a survey conducted by the Pew Research Center on the role of social networks and the internet during the 2010 election cycle. According to the survey's findings, "one in five adults who use the Internet, including a growing number of older, conservative Republicans, turned to social networks to get or share information about the midterm elections last year" (Preston). In addition, the study showed that 53% of Internet users went online to engage in a campaign-related activity (watching a political video, fact checking a political claim, or sharing and discussing information).

The results of this survey emphasize the important role that social networks like Twitter and Facebook, and new media technology in general, are going to play in the 2012 Presidential Campaign (Aaron Smith, Pew Center). It is often said that part of the reason President Obama's 2008 Presidential campaign was so successful is because it used social media in new and innovative ways to garner support around the country.


Candidates are learning from 2008's best practices, however, and as another study from the Pew Research Center entitled "22% of online Americans used social networking or Twitter for politics in 2010 campaign" points out, "Republicans, who lagged behind Democrats in the 2008 campaign in some key aspects of social media use, caught up to Democrats in the midterm election cycle" (Smith). Furthermore, these political social media users voted for Republican congressional candidates over Democratic candidates by a 45%-41% margin, and Republicans' enthusiasm for using social media matched that of Democrats. Think back to the political organizing success of the Tea Party Movement during the 2010 election cycle, due in large part to social media. Therefore, the midterms demonstrated the potential and power of these online tools--two thirds of Republican and Democratic candidates used them for the first time in 2010. All of a sudden, "The notion that the Internet was owned by liberals, owned by the left in the wake of the Obama victory, has been proven false" (Patrick Ruffini, Republican political online strategist).

More and more people are turning to these new media sources for their information, but what is the quality of that information? 61% of adults surveyed agreed that the Internet exposed them to a wider range of political views than they might get from traditional news sources, but they expressed concerns about "the quality and value of the information they were finding" (Preston). What is more troubling is that 56% of Internet users find it difficult to differentiate between true information and false information on the Internet.

Alan Rosenblatt (Center for American Progress Action Fund) explains that this lack of trust is what drives people to use social networking sites: that is where they get information and opinions from trusted friends. But, if a person is getting their political information only from their circle of trusted friends, it is likely that these friends already share the same views as this person. By extension, if a person relies solely on social networking sites for their information, are they really getting a wide range of political views?


The major role that new media and social networking sites have played in elections thus far, combined with the potentially viral dissemination of true or false information on the Internet, mean that the 2012 elections--particularly the Presidential race--will be exciting, frustrating, and most of all, unpredictable.

Sunday, March 27, 2011

Out with the Old, and in with the NEWER New Media

Technology is constantly trying to advance the way we do things by making the process easier and quicker. Apparently, America's youth no longer has the patience to share their thoughts by sitting and writing a lengthy blogpost; instead they turn to Twitter and Facebook to share their thoughts via length-restricted statuses and tweets.

This New York Times article "Blogs Wane as the Young Drift to Sites like Twitter" explains, "Former bloggers said they were too busy to write lengthy posts and were uninspired by a lack of readers. Others said they had no interest in creating a blog because social networking did a good enough job keeping them in touch with friends and family" (Kopytoff). The Internet and American Life Project at the Pew Research Center found that from 2006 to 2009, blogging amongst children ages 12-17 fell by half so that now only 14% of that age group who use the Internet have blogs. Among 18-to-33-year-olds, the project said in a report last year, blogging dropped two percentage points in 2010 from two years earlier.

Now, people feel they can share their life in a quicker and easier fashion through these other platforms, and they're getting more hits this way as well. The NYT article goes on to explain that some bloggers are using Facebook and Twitter to help promote their blogposts to a wider audience, so that instead of being competitors, blogs and social networking sites are actually complementary.

Interestingly, however, although the youth demographic is losing interest in blogging, the older generations are sticking with it. "Among 34-to-45-year-olds who use the Internet, the percentage who blog increased six points, to 16 percent, in 2010 from two years earlier, the Pew survey found. Blogging by 46-to-55-year-olds increased five percentage points, to 11 percent, while blogging among 65-to-73-year-olds rose two percentage points, to 8 percent" (Kopytoff).

What accounts for the growing decline of blogging amongst today's youth? Is it laziness, boredom, lack of free time, short attention spans? If today's youth no longer want to take the time to write blogposts (nor, presumably, to sit down and read others' blogposts) because they would much rather have their news synthesized in 140 characters, what does that mean for the future of other more traditional news sources? And if today's youth is losing its interest in longer, nuanced prose, what does this mean for the future of civic engagement and the democratic process?

Blogs, Tweets, and YouTube Videos are all about Japan

From March 14-18, 2011 the earthquake in Japan and the aftermath was the number one topic on blogs, Twitter, and YouTube, according to the New Media Index from the Pew Research Center's Project for Excellence in Journalism. This is the second time that one story has dominated in these three new media platforms; the first story to do this was the unrest that followed the Iranian elections in June 2009. According to the Pew's New Media Index, 64% of news links on blogs, 32% of news links on Twitter, and all of the top 20 videos on YouTube were about the earthquake in Japan. What's interesting about these findings, as well as the article that accompanies them, is that it discusses how each social media platform functions using different techniques. Blogs were able to pull on the emotional content of the event, Twitter kept followers updated about headlines and new events as they happened, and YouTube provided the dramatic video footage that allowed a viewer to see what the tsunami looked like as it barreled into Japan's coast. In order for a story to be so widely reported on across all three platforms it must possess elements that each new media outlet can build on and intrigue readers, followers, and viewers with. The fact that this has only happened once before speaks to the unique combination of qualities that a story must possess in order to dominate all three outlets.

Cameroon Bans Twitter SMS until further notice

This article was posted on Passport, a blog run by Foreign Policy Magazine, and it takes a very clear stance on the Cameroonian’s government decision to ban Twitter Mobile SMS posts. Scholars and news media are frequently citing the critical role that Twitter played in facilitating the Orange and Iranian Revolutions and, even more recently, in the ongoing protests in Egypt. This story provided an interesting case study for governments that wish to quell homegrown revolutions and raised questions about the new form of online activism. In the end, through the use of quotations, it argued that banning SMS Twitter will be an ineffective way of quieting protestors or government critics.
While this article did not give a lot of background information on Twitter’s revolutionary capacity, it cited a blogger, Dibussi Tande, from Cameroon, who described the use of SMS Twitter updates in the Tunisia protests. Tande’s blog won the 2008 Black Weblog Awards for Best International Blog. It also cites Evgeny Morozov, author of The Dark Side of Internet Freedom: The New Delusion, to argues against the Cameroonian government’s adoption of this ill-conceived policy. While I appreciated the research that went into this brief Passport post, I think it would have been nice for the Foreign Policy editors to take more a clear position on the Cameroonian government’s decision to block mobile twitter.