Wednesday, April 27, 2011

Royal Wedding Watch: No Tweeting Allowed

Just to continue with the Royal Wedding's presence in the Twitterworld, I felt a brief update was necessary.  While correspondents from all the major news conglomerates will be outside the gates tweeting as fast as their fingers can move.  But as for those lucky enough to score an invitation, don't expect any activity on their Twitter accounts.  Although Scotland Yard has clarified that the rumored cell-signal blocking device will not be used, cell phones have still been banned from the ceremony.

Information came from a Washington Post report. 

Monday, April 25, 2011

Royal Wedding Watch: The Naysayers

#RoyalWedding, #rw11, #rw2011, #proudtobebritsh and more.  All are hash tags created as a result of the wedding between Kate and William that will take place on April 29.  And some of them have started trending long before the nuptials are set to take place.  But one does not fit with the rest: #royalpain.  Earlier today, the Washington Post put out a message into the Tweetosphere asking for the underrepresented portion of the community to respond.
While it seems as though The WP was looking for genuine opinions of disapproval for the Wedding (and they did get a handful of those) what they got more was a slap on the hands.  People criticized them, and other news sites, for devoting too much attention to the wedding when there are other, more pressing, issues at hand.      


Online options for the news allow for even the less than important news to be published.  And while it doesn't take up print space, it is consuming time of reporters.  And people are taking notice and voicing their opinions on this new approach to reporting and what gets reported.  




A giant scale Lego replica of the royal ceremony? Seriously? (AFP/GETTY IMAGES)

Sunday, April 24, 2011

Drowning in Social Media: Filtering the Social Web to get the News You Need

In today's world of new media, where a person can get news from the blogosphere, Twitter, Facebook, etc. people can easily feel as though they're drowning in too much information. The New York Times published an article explaining that as a result of that feeling, there is now a need to filter all of this information to make it easier for people to get their daily dose of news.

The article cites the commercial jet landing in the Hudson River and the uprisings in Egypt as examples of regular people--not reporters--who are breaking news by uploading Twitter posts, photos, and videos to the Web. As a result, there is now a huge surplus of information coming in from all directions. How are people supposed to sift through the noise? One of the senior strategists at NPR explains, “There’s a big need for tools that allow people to collect bits of social media context and organize them in some fashion.”

A Web start-up called Storify aims to help journalists and others collect and filter all of this information. "Using the Storify Web site, people can find and piece together publicly available content from Twitter, Flickr, Facebook, YouTube, and other sites. They can also add text and embed the resulting collages of content on their own sites." Storify is one of many Web start-ups working towards this goal so that journalists can sift through all of the information and publish the most relevant items.

One of the founders of Storify explains, "Even though journalists may not be the first on the scene, they select the most reliable sources, digest loads of information and provide context for events. We have so many real-time streams now, we’re all drowning. So the idea of Storify is to pick out the most important pieces, amplify them and give them context."

Furthermore, it is interesting to consider the fact that the news media no longer has exclusivity on sharing and publishing information. If the average Joe breaks a story on his Twitter and then immediately posts videos of the event on his YouTube, will the New York Times' coverage really be breaking news anymore? What is the difference between a traditional news source, like the New York Times, covering a story and a well-informed citizen covering the story through his own social media?

Does the influence of technology mean that the 21st-century role of the news media will be based less on investigating and reporting, and more on sifting and organizing? Will reporters now rely more on average people to provide information, and on their own professional judgment to choose which stories are newsworthy? Or can traditional news media still exist with new social media providing a complementary set of news? Will the increased power of the people exacerbate the 24-hour news cycle, or will the laypeople's influence force the news media to dig deeper into the issues that people truly care about?

Twitter (as used by Susan Orlean)

Like many others I have some concerns about Twitter and its impact on how people flesh out ideas, particularly when only 140 characters are allowed. In a recent post on PBS's MediaShift website Simon Owens discusses how New Yorker writer, Susan Orlean, uses Twitter. Orlean discusses how when she first got a Twitter account she didn't really understand the purpose of it, but after a few years she figured out how to use the platform to develop a type of back-and-forth with her readers. She describes it as an "ongoing Q&A session." It provided her with a mechanism for staying in contact with readers between New Yorker pieces and while working on books. Before Twitter she could go months without publishing anything, however Twitter allows her to stay in contact with the world and keep them up-to-date on her work. Perhaps Twitter can allow for dialogue in a way that is more purposeful than 140 characters may lead one to believe. However, my guess is that those who engage and follow Orlean, and Orlean herself, are likely to find ways to engage in meaningful dialogue with or without Twitter. This platform just happens to be the current forum for exchange. Nevertheless, any mechanism for allowing journalists and writers to connect with readers and introduce them to their work must serve some greater purpose.


Saturday, April 23, 2011

2012 Elections and the Race to Newer "New Media"

With the 2012 Presidential Election gearing up and likely to soon be dominating media coverage, candidates are looking for a way to spread their political message through new media forums. President Barack Obama was known for his innovate use of social media, grassroots politics, and for mobilizing the youth vote. This article by Rob Salkowitz, author of Young World Rising: How Youth Technology and Entrepreneurship are Changing the World from the Bottom Up, share his predication for the role new media will play in the upcoming election.
One issues that I think this article does a nice job of focusing on is the speed at which social media is evolving. The 2004 election was arguably the first major election to be influence by the rise of social media and, since then, politicians have been searching for ways to creatively promote their message on the internet. One of the benefits of social networking for politicians is that this type of media is relatively low cost, especially when compared to television and newspaper advertisements. Salkowitz points out that the biggest factor in the next election will be figuring out to turn this low cost media into a profitable venture. For example, instead of using new media just to share a message, a politicians will have to use new media to get more donations to their campaign. While this article does not necessarily frame any new media technology as most useful than another, it does make some valid points of about the limitations of recent developments. It seems that applications, like FourSquare and “video-on-demand” improvements, will be unable to make substantial improvements to a candidate’s message. This article does a good job of balancing the potential benefits of newer media tools in the upcoming elections, with limitations that candidates will face in developing their online strategies.

@acarvin

As Twitter becomes a popular way for empowering individuals to share their own experiences and communicate with each other, some questions have been raised about its viability as a form of journalism. To some, allows “everyday citizens” to become journalist seems like it would destroy a level of professionalism and trust that is necessary for reporting current events. Twitter has given individuals involved in the Middle East uprisings a platform to share their opinion and stories. However, this style also raises some important questions: How do we know who to trust? If I am not interested in learning about an opinion, is it possible for me to selectively avoid it? What does this mean for larger media entities?
This USA Today article focuses on how Andy Carvin, an NPR senior strategist focusing on social media, deals with some of these issues and has earned him the reputation as the “maestro of the [Middle East region’s] Twitter feed” and one of Time Magazine’s 100 most influential people. Personally, I started following Carvin a few months ago and have found that his tweets on the revolutions in the Middle East to be the most accurate and informational. As a member of a professional media outlet, Carvin works to find reliable sources of information and uses his own Twitter feed as an aggregator. Carvin’s Twitter style seems to be one way that larger media outlets or professional journalists can use new media to their advantage and diversity their source information.

Freedom vs. Facebook

As I have discussed before, Facebook has ramped up its lobbying efforts, which has drawn increased coverage across the news media. The Wall Street Journal published a particularly interesting article about this topic where it discusses Facebook's efforts to access the Chinese market, which has been closed since 2009. In the process of trying to access China, Facebook is also dealing with difficult questions of censorship and freedom of speech. In the WSJ article, Adam Connor, a Facebook lobbyist, says,
"Maybe we will block content in some countries, but not others...We are occasionally held in uncomfortable positions because now we're allowing too much, maybe, free speech in countries that haven't experienced it before."
The question of how much freedom of speech to allow is difficult to answer, particularly when there are authoritarian regimes involved. However, Facebook is often praised for allowing individuals to share thoughts with one another unfiltered. It has also been championed as a means for organizing individuals precisely when their freedoms are threatened or not granted. If Facebook decides to block content in certain countries it will seriously be doing itself a disfavor as an information provider. While we do not necessarily demand the same democratic responsibility from social media sites as we do from traditional news media, the question comes up of whether or not we should. To what extent should we treat Facebook's possible censorship decisions as part of business? Or should we demand more from a site that portrays itself as doing more than traditional business does? What is the democratic responsibility of social media and to what standard should we hold it? If censorship is allowed, some of the valuable things that social media platforms are praised for doing, such as disseminating information quickly and mobilizing individuals around a cause, might not happen.